Quick Banner Elk NC MLS Search

Browse All Banner Elk NC Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$449,000
3.5 Acres ACTIVE Status
Discover the exceptional opportunity to build your dream home on Lot S124, an expansive 3.5-acre estate nestled in the coveted Sunset section of The Lodges at Eagles Nest. This premier lot offers privacy, space, and breathtaking panoramic long-range layered sunset views that will captivate you every evening. Situated in one of the most desirable neighborhoods, Lot S124 combines natural beauty with convenient access to all the luxurious amenities Eagles Nest has to offer. The gently sloping terrain lends itself to creative architectural designs, allowing you to take full advantage of the dramatic vistas and serene landscape. Whether you envision a cozy retreat or an impressive estate, this site provides the perfect canvas. The Sunset section is renowned for its tranquil environment, surrounded by pristine nature and mature trees. Experience tranquil morning sunrises and vibrant evening skies framed by mountain and valley views that evolve with the seasons. Enjoy outdoor living at its finest with ample space for patios, pools, gardens, and entertaining areas designed to maximize the captivating scenery. The Lodges at Eagles Nest offers a lifestyle with access to hiking trails, club amenities, and proximity to nearby towns, ensuring a perfect blend of seclusion and convenience. This lot invites you to embrace the peaceful mountain lifestyle while remaining connected to modern comforts. Don’t miss the chance to own a piece of paradise on Lot S124 — an extraordinary setting where every sunset paints a masterpiece, and where your vision for luxury living can become a reality. Schedule a tour today and explore the possibilities that await in this stunning location.

S-124 Silver Eagle Trail, Banner Elk

$500,000
1 Beds 1 Baths 520 SqFt. 0.88 Acres ACTIVE Status
Tucked away along the river in the heart of the High Country, this charming mountain retreat offers a rare combination of river frontage, privacy and convenient access to Valle Crucis, Boone and Banner Elk. Situated on 0.89 acre, the one-level home provides an inviting escape where the sounds and views of the river create a peaceful mountain setting. The land is incredibly gentle, fully useable. The thoughtfully designed interior features one bedroom and one full bath, along with an open living, dining and kitchen area. Wood accents and a comfortable mountain aesthetic complement the natural surroundings, while covered and open deck areas provide wonderful spaces to relax outdoors, listen to the river and enjoy the cool mountain air. The property features river frontage and river views, a shared paved driveway and private paved road access. A metal roof, wood exterior and classic mountain architecture add to the home's rustic character. Fiber-optic and high-speed internet availability make it possible to stay connected while enjoying a quieter mountain lifestyle. With both short-term and long-term rentals permitted, the property offers flexibility as a personal getaway, investment property or combination of the two. Conveniently located off DeWitt Barnett Road near Valle Crucis, with easy access to Highway 105, this is an excellent base for enjoying everything the High Country has to offer. Whether you're looking for a weekend escape, mountain rental or simply a peaceful place along the river, 151 Red Tailed Hawk Road offers an opportunity to own a special piece of the North Carolina mountains.

151 Red Tailed Hawk Road, Banner Elk

$425,000
2.63 Acres ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Positioned on 2.63 acres within the Sunset section of The Lodges at Eagles Nest, Homesite S-90 is defined by its exceptional western exposure, gently sloping topography, and panoramic long-range mountain views. Rising to approximately 4,375 feet in elevation, the property offers an outstanding setting for enjoying the ever-changing colors of the Blue Ridge Mountains, where evenings are often marked by remarkable sunsets stretching across layers of distant ridgelines. Mature hardwoods frame the homesite while generous road frontage and a thoughtfully positioned building envelope provide both flexibility in home design and an exceptional connection to the surrounding landscape. The Sunset section allows homes beginning at just 1,200 heated square feet, offering the opportunity to create a wide range of custom mountain homes. Located on the southern side of Eagles Nest, owners enjoy convenient access to the community's main entrance, The Great Camp, Epic Chophouse, and the many lifestyle amenities that make Eagles Nest one of North Carolina's premier luxury mountain communities. Encompassing more than 3,000 acres with elevations exceeding 5,200 feet, The Lodges at Eagles Nest offers an extraordinary collection of amenities including Eagles Nest Winery, Camp Eagles Nest, The North Pavilion, Eagles Nest River Club, miles of hiking, mountain biking and ATV trails, waterfalls, streams, dramatic rock outcroppings, sports courts, and year-round opportunities to experience the beauty of the Blue Ridge Mountains. For buyers seeking elevated western views, exceptional buildability, generous acreage, and one of the community's most scenic settings, Homesite S-90 presents a remarkable opportunity to experience the beauty of Eagles Nest from sunrise to sunset.

S-90 Talon Drive, Banner Elk

$420,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 1,875 SqFt. 0.26 Acres ACTIVE Status
Take a fresh look! Complete exterior & interior repaint just completed this month!! Rare Opportunity!! Only listing like this in downtown Banner Elk; Set up as a duplex (but could be used as a single family with a rental income apartment (recently rented both units for total $3000/month! No lease/ tenants in place now to make it easy to show/ sell), or with the stairs from the main level down to the workshop/garage, it could easily be finished out as a 5/3 home with an extra living/kitchen below) that is walking distance to town!!! It's very rare for any multi-family to come on the market in Downtown Banner Elk on city water/sewer/maintained-paved roads, and this investment has been a great asset for 11 years to the current owner. Easily accessible with paved driveway, and fully remodeled when purchased, including metal roof, new kitchens, new baths, new plumbing, new windows, lvp flooring, etc, the duplex features a 2/1 below, and a 3/2 above, with separate entrances/decks. The basement features a 1-car garage and large workshop area (this is set up to be assessed by either unit, depending on which wants to include it in their lease). There is a small flat yard around the lower unit. Old Turnpike runs next to a noisy creek, and is a quiet, flat street that is great for walking. In past tenants pay all utilities 50/50 between the units; with power on 1 meter. Ready now to move-in!

173 Old Turnpike NW Road, Banner Elk

$494,500
2 Beds 3 Baths 1,236 SqFt. 2.17 Acres ACTIVE Status
Set on 2.17 peaceful acres with beautiful, long-range views of layered mountains and pastoral landscapes, this 1910 farmhouse offers a quiet retreat deeply rooted in its natural surroundings. Fully renovated in 2019, the home features two bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and an inviting interior updated with 2020 interior paint and new window treatments in the primary and guest bedrooms. The main level includes an updated kitchen with a 2022 refrigerator and a newly installed 2025 dishwasher, a dining room with a new chandelier, forced-air propane heating, and an included washer and dryer. Upstairs, a versatile bonus area provides an extra bedroom and an office or play space, offering significant functional room not counted in the heated square footage due to ceilings just under seven feet. Outside, the exceptionally quiet grounds invite exploration and relaxation, featuring three distinct ponds, an established kitchen garden yielding fresh fruits and vegetables, stone-bordered flower beds, and a fire pit. An expansive deck, extended in 2020 and freshly stained in 2026, provides an ideal vantage point for enjoying the serene environment and ample mountain sunshine. Practical property features include an outdoor cellar for extra storage, new gutters and exterior paint completed in 2023, and a new gravel driveway from 2026 that offers generous parking. Notably, the property and its surrounding land sustained no damage from Hurricane Helene. Offering a genuine sense of seclusion and tranquility without sacrificing convenience, this beautiful property sits just eight minutes from Banner Elk Winery, nine minutes from downtown Banner Elk, and eleven minutes from Valle Crucis.

1193 Oliver Hill Road, Banner Elk

$469,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 1,384 SqFt. 0.55 Acres ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Answer the call of the mountains with this 2 bedroom, 2 bath log-sided cabin in Banner Elk. 50 Cabin Ridge Lane sits halfway between Banner Elk, with its activities and dining options, and Newland, where crowds are minimal. It's about 4 miles to either, and just 7 miles from Sugar Mountain, with Beech Mountain ski resort around 9 miles away. The covered front porch is well suited to a morning cup of coffee in the rockers or an evening at the grill. The large rear deck offers space for gathering with friends and family around the fire pit for s'mores or a glass of wine from one of the local wineries, and it was engineered and built to support a future spa. Inside, large windows in the family room fill the space with natural light and give the feel of sitting in a treehouse, where a cozy stone fireplace with a gas insert anchors the room. A well-sized kitchen and dining area complete the main living space. At the rear of the home, two bedrooms share a full bathroom. Upstairs, a large loft is currently used as additional sleeping quarters with a king-size bed, alongside a nook with a double Murphy bed offering flexible space for a home office or additional guests, plus a second full bathroom. Furnished and turnkey with minor exclusions, 50 Cabin Ridge Lane has been a family retreat for years of gathering and making mountain memories, with easy access to skiing, dining, and the shops of the High Country. It's a proven mountain retreat with strong second-home and rental appeal. Back on the market with the prior buyer's full inspection reports being made available to the next buyer at no cost, a head start on due diligence.

50 Cabin Ridge Lane, Banner Elk

$425,000
1 Beds 2 Baths 1,316 SqFt. 3 Acres ACTIVE Status
Discover the perfect High Country retreat in the heart of the Valle Crucis community, ideally situated between Boone and Banner Elk. This charming 1-bedroom, 2-bath mountain cottage features a loft used as an additional sleeping area, offering comfort, flexibility, and the quintessential mountain-living experience. Set on 3 beautifully landscaped acres, the property is bordered by a serene rhododendron-lined creek, creating a peaceful natural backdrop. Enjoy the cool mountain climate from the covered deck, where the little creek sets the tone for relaxation. Inside, the cottage offers warm, inviting living spaces, while outside, the property shines with exceptional functionality. A 1,250-square-foot detached 2-car garage includes a large workshop and storage area for hobbies, equipment, or outdoor gear. A semi-circle driveway provides easy access and ample parking. Located just minutes from some of the area’s most beloved attractions, you’ll have quick access to hiking, fishing, skiing, golf, tennis, and biking, along with the charm and conveniences of the Valle Crucis community. The home is part of a well-run POA in a long-established neighborhood, offering peace of mind and a sense of community. Whether you’re seeking a full-time residence, a mountain getaway, or an investment opportunity, this creekside cottage delivers the perfect blend of privacy, natural beauty, and convenience.

187 Little Creekside, Banner Elk

$489,900
8.52 Acres ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Discover this expansive 8.52-acre mountain homesite positioned mid-mountain within the established community of The Lodges at Eagles Nest in Banner Elk, North Carolina. Lot 53 showcases panoramic, long-range northeastern views that capture the layers of the Blue Ridge Mountains and breathtaking high-country sunrises. The generous acreage provides an optimal building topography for a customized multi-level mountain retreat designed to maximize the sweeping ridgeline vistas. Property owners enjoy a prime central location with immediate, walking-distance access to Camp Eagles Nest, a major recreational hub in the community. Camp Eagles Nest provides a diverse lineup of amenities just steps from the lot boundary, including tennis courts, pickleball courts, a basketball court, a state-of-the-art children's playground, and a stocked fishing pond. An extensive network of scenic hiking and mountain biking trails directly intersects this section of the mountain, allowing outdoor enthusiasts to explore thousands of acres of preserved forest land. This location also sits in close proximity to the Beech Mountain connector, allowing you to bypass main roads and find yourself on the premier ski slopes of Beech Mountain Resort in less than 10 minutes. Beyond the immediate neighborhood features, property owners receive access to the wider amenities across the development, most notably the direct membership access to Epic Chophouse at Eagles Nest. Situated at Great Camp at a spectacular 4,300-foot elevation, this fine-dining mountain lodge offers an unparalleled culinary experience with wet-aged steaks and expansive glass walls framing 50-mile views. For buyers interested in generating rental income, the community allows short-term rentals, giving guests access to these premier facilities—including Epic Chophouse—during their stay. This expansive parcel combines rare mid-mountain acreage, prominent northeastern exposure, immediate trail systems, and rapid winter sport access, making it an exceptional opportunity to establish a lasting mountain legacy in the High Country.

53 Eagle Creek Trail, Banner Elk

$450,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 1,981 SqFt. 1.57 Acres ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Less than five minutes from downtown Banner Elk, Lees-McRae College and Sugar Mountain, this single-level ranch residence offers location, flexibility and privacy on a park-like, flat 1.57-acre setting. While officially listed as a three-bedroom home, the layout provides four distinct sleeping areas, including a versatile guest suite off the kitchen with its stone fireplace, full bath, walk-in closet, private deck and abundant natural light, ideal as a second primary suite, in-law space or bonus living area. The open kitchen and dining area flow into the main living room, which features a second stone fireplace crafted from Grandfather Mountain stone. French doors lead to a large rear deck overlooking the fenced backyard, garden space and wooded edge. The same Grandfather Mountain stone is used on the exterior, adding timeless character and regional significance. One bedroom is used as a laundry room and can be easily converted back. The unfinished basement offers a second laundry area, abundant storage and space for a gym, studio or workshop. Outdoor living is unmatched, with a covered front porch, expansive back deck, stone path to a creekside platform beneath a mature shade tree, and ample room for gardening or small livestock. A heated, detached two-car garage with workshop or office is connected by a covered breezeway. Additional features include accessible design elements and a high-efficiency HVAC system with advanced air filtration. A rare opportunity combining convenience, unrestricted usable land and flexible living space, minutes from everything Banner Elk and the High Country have to offer.

6670 Hickory Nut Gap Road, Banner Elk

Start Your Search

The information from this search is provided by the High 'Country Multiple Listing Service. Please be aware that not all listings produced from this search will be of this real estate company. All information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Please verify all property information before entering into a purchase.”

Between $400K - $500K Banner Elk Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Banner Elk and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!